I'd appreciate hearing your top five English mentholated snuffs.
I returned to snuff last year when I discovered some McChrystal's O&G and Olde English at Boswell's Pipe Shop* when I went to retrieve a pipe that I had cleaned. The O&G was 'ok' but I was surprised how quickly I went through the Olde English. I then ordered a bunch of German snuffs from Toque but wasn't especially taken by any of them. For my next order, I'd like some guidance on what to order along with Olde English.
*For those who live in Pennsylvania, the shop I visited was the one in Chambersburg, though I understand both of Boswell's shops carry snuff. From speaking with Archie who was manning the shop when I went, both shops carry snuff but only from McChrystals. When I went to Boswell's they only had the O&G and Olde English in the 8.75g tins but was told that they normally have more scents. Both snuffs were fresh. Archie said that snuffs smell relatively briskly largely because a few people buy numerous tins at a time. a For what it's worth the cost of each tin was $3.99. I suppose I should add that Boswell's will not ship snuff.